Malaria in Michigan?

David McCormick

David McCormick

When you think about malaria, chances are high that the United States is not the first country that comes to mind.  However, malaria was endemic in the US until the late 1940’s, and the high prevalence of malaria in the Southeastern US is one of the main reasons why the CDC headquarters is located in Atlanta.

Malaria has a long history in the US.  Until 1880 it was thought that malaria was caused by bad air (“malaria” comes from the Medieval Italian for “bad air”) and it wasn’t until 1898 that Sir Ronald Ross of Britain proved that malaria is transmitted by mosquitos.  Our capital was built on a swamp (truly a wonder of modern urban planning) and in the summer was notorious for diseases including malaria and yellow fever.

It’s easy to forget that until as recently as a century ago, much of the US was still a developing country – industrial manufacturing was low and most people lived in small towns and worked on family farms.  The population density was low in many regions and low-lying fields were good farmland and ideal breeding grounds for the mosquitoes that carried malaria when they flooded.  Malaria was such a problem in the US that the US Census of 1870 released a map showing areas in the US where deaths from malaria were high (see below).

A Census Map Showing the Proportionate Mortality of Malaria in the US in 1870

The map is courtesy of the US Library of Congress and can be found in its original context here.

Michigan’s reputation as a hotbed of malaria was well known, as the following quote from the Bulletin of the Medical and Surgical Sanitorium (Battle Creek, Michigan, 1892) shows:

But what about Michigan malaria? Unfortunately for the reputation of Michigan as a healthful State, the idea got abroad many years ago that the principal feature of its climate was malaria. Going to Michigan was considered almost synonymous with going to have a fit of the ague. It was not supposed to be possible for a person to visit Michigan or even to pass through the State without having the chills.

Apart from being a mere historical curiosity, the high prevalence of malaria in Michigan served as a barrier to development – the rural regions of Central Michigan stand in sharp contrast to the well-developed Southeast and are a legacy of peoples’ hesitancy to venture further inland.

So how did we eradicate malaria in the United States?  Public health.  Even before it was known that malaria was transmitted by mosquitoes, people would clear swamps to reduce the incidence – a classic example of how you can solve a health problem without knowing the exact cause of disease if you understand the risk factors.  Once we figured out that mosquitoes were the culprit, much of the eradication effort focused on their elimination.  Common practices included land improvement, removal of mosquito breeding sites, and heavy insecticide use.  DDT was the most commonly used insecticide, and its use in the 1940’s to eliminate malaria lead to severe environmental consequences (for more, see Silent Spring). A very nice (and brief) history can be found here.

5 thoughts on “Malaria in Michigan?

  1. Pingback: Malaria – A Brief Medical Report | Mouthparts:

  2. I went to Ivory Coast in 1974 and came back with full blown malaria. I lived in Northport, Michigan. I had plasmodium malaria and cerebral malaria. sick with constant diarea for a week then delerious for another week before my parents called an ambulance. in hospital 2 months. 195 before and when I was able to stand I weighed 135, I was 18.

  3. Nice history. I like the map. I lived in Africa for several decades and had malaria a time or two. But your statement about DDT is wrong. Banning it has cost millions of lives, and saving lives is why is has been brought back in southern Africa.

    “In 1970, the National Academy of Sciences wrote in a report that ”to only a few chemicals does man owe as great a debt as to DDT” and it credited the insecticide with preventing as many as 500,000,000 human deaths.”

    See for example, http://directorblue.blogspot.com/2009/03/genocide-in-green.html

  4. Pingback: Way OT Ebola - Page 19

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s